Showing posts with label rulemaking. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rulemaking. Show all posts

Thursday, January 12, 2017

CONYERS Floor Statement In Opposition To The So-Called "Regulatory Accountability Act 2017

OPENING STATEMENT


I rise in strong opposition to H.R. 5, the “Regulatory Accountability Act.”
           
Under the guise of improving the regulatory process, H.R. 5 will, in truth, undermine that process and jeopardize the ability of government agencies to safeguard public health and safety, the environment, workplace safety, and consumer financial protections. 

The ways in which this legislation accomplishes this result are almost too numerous to list here, but I will mention a few. 

For example, title I of the bill would impose more than 70 new analytical requirements that will add years to the rulemaking process. 

Worse yet, many of these new requirements are intended to facilitate the ability of regulated entities -- such as well-funded corporate interests -- to intervene and derail regulatory protections they oppose. 

And, it would function as a “super mandate,” overriding critical laws that Congress specifically intended to prohibit agencies from considering costs when American lives are at stake. 

Additionally, the bill creates numerous procedural hurdles in the rulemaking process, further endangering American lives through years of delay and increasing the likelihood of regulatory capture. 

For example, H.R. 5 dramatically expands the use of formal rulemaking, a time- and resource-intensive process, requiring formal trial-like hearings for certain rules.

Formal rulemaking has long been roundly rejected for good cause as being excessively costly and ill-suited for complex policy issues. 

The Administrative Section of the American Bar Association noted that “these provisions run directly contrary to a virtual consensus in the administrative law community that the Administrative Procedure Act formal rulemaking procedure is obsolete.” 

I am also concerned that H.R. 5 would impose an arbitrary one-size-fits-all 6-month delay on virtually every new rule.

Specifically, title V of the bill will prohibit agency rules from becoming effective until the information required by the bill has been available online for 6 months, with only limited exception. 

Clearly, H.R. 5 fails to take into account a vast array of time-sensitive rules ranging from the mundane -- such as the frequent U.S. Coast Guard bridge closings regulations -- to those that protect public health and safety, such as forthcoming updates to the Lead and Copper Rule by the Environmental Protection Agency to reduce lead in public drinking water.

Finally, title II of H.R. 5 would eliminate judicial deference to agencies and require federal courts to review all agency rulemakings and interpretations of statutes on a de novo basis.

The unfortunate result of this requirement is that the bill would empower a generalist court to override the determinations of agency experts, regardless of the judge’s technical knowledge and understanding of the underlying subject matter.

By eliminating any deference to agencies, H.R. 5 would force agencies to adopt even moredetailed factual records and explanations, which would further delay the finalization of critical life-saving regulatory protections.

The Supreme Court has recognized that federal courts simply lack the subject-matter expertise of agencies, are politically unaccountable, and should not engage in making substantive determinations from the bench.

It is ironic that those who have long decried “judicial activism” now support facilitating a greater role for the judiciary in agency rulemaking.

These are just a few of the many serious concerns presented by H.R. 5 and, accordingly, I urge my colleagues to oppose this dangerous legislation and I reserve the balance of my time.


CLOSING REMARKS


I oppose H.R. 5 because it is based on the faulty premise that environmental and public safety protections kill jobs, result in economically stifling costs, and promote uncertainty.

This bill would not create a single job.  During the series of hearings and markups held on this anti-regulatory legislation in previous congresses, not one shred of evidence emerged indicating that this bill would create jobs.

To the contrary, the Majority’s own witness, Christopher DeMuth, appearing on behalf of the conservative think tank American Enterprise Institute, debunked this argument, stating that focusing on jobs “can lead to confusion in regulatory debates” and that the employment effects of regulatory protections “are indeterminate.”

In sharp contrast to the misguided approach of H.R. 5, regulatory protections that ensure the safety of American-made products unquestionably foster job creation and protect the competitiveness of our businesses in the global marketplace. 

This explains why more than 150 organizations strongly oppose this dangerous legislation, including:
·                     Americans for Financial Reform
·                     The American Lung Association
·                     Consumers Union
·                     The Humane Society of the United States
·                     The League of Conservation Voters
·                     Public Citizen
·                     The American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees
·                     Earthjustice
·                     The Coalition for Sensible Safeguards
·                     The American Public Health Association
·                     The Environmental Defense Action Fund
·                     The Center for American Progress, and
·                     The Trust for America’s Health.

The American people deserve better than H.R. 5. 

We need legislation that creates middle class financial security and opportunity.
           
We need sensible regulations that protect American families from economic ruin and that bring predatory financial practices to an end.

We need workplace safety protections that ensure hardworking Americans who go to work each day without having to risk their lives as a result of hazardous work environments.

Unfortunately, H.R. 5 does nothing to advance any of these critical goals. 

I must therefore oppose H.R. 5 and I yield back the balance of my time.

Voting is beautiful, be beautiful ~ vote.©

Wednesday, September 21, 2016

Floor Statement of the Honorable John Conyers Jr. in Opposition to H.R. 3438, the “Require Evaluation before Implementing Executive Wishlists Act of 2016”


Dean of the U.S. House
of Representatives
John Conyers, Jr.
H.R. 3438, the “Require Evaluation before Implementing Executive Wishlists Act of 2016,” would stay the enforcement of any rule imposing an annual cost to the economy in excess of $1 billion pending judicial review.

Notwithstanding the bill’s colorful short title, H.R. 3438 would have a pernicious impact on rulemaking and the ability of agencies to respond to critical health and safety issues.

In essence, the bill would encourage anyone who wants to delay a significant rule from going into effect by simply seeking judicial review of the rule.

We all know that the judicial review process can take months, if not years to finalize, especially if the appellate process reaches the United States Supreme Court.

Thus, rather than ensuring predictability and streamlining the rulemaking process, this bill would have a completely opposite impact by making the process less predictable and more time-consuming.

Equally important, H.R. 3438 has absolutely no health or safety emergency exceptions. If anything, this bill would empower the very entities that caused a serious health or safety risk to delay –and possibly derail—legitimate efforts by regulatory agencies to respond to such threats.

And, as with other bills proposed by my colleagues on the other side of the aisle, this legislation myopically focuses only on the cost of a proposed rule, while ignoring the rule’s benefits, which often exceed its cost by many multiples.

In closing, there is broad agreement among experts in the administrative law field that our Nation’s regulatory system is already too cumbersome and slow-moving.

In addition to the Administrative Procedure Act’s procedural mechanisms – which are designed to ensure an open and fair rulemaking system -- Congress has passed various additional federal laws that impose further rulemaking requirements. 

And, rulemaking agencies must also comply with a number of Executive Orders issued over the past several decades that have created additional layers of analytical and procedural requirements.

The result of this dense web of existing requirements is a complex, time-consuming rulemaking process.

In response to the explosion of analytical requirements imposed on the rulemaking process, the American Bar Association, as well as many administrative law experts, have urged Congress to exercise restraint and assess the usefulness of existing requirements before considering sweeping legislation.

Imposing new analytical and procedural requirements on the administrative system also carries real human and economic costs.

As Robert Weissman, the President of Public Citizen, has observed, the cost of regulatory delay is “far more severe than generic inefficiency. Lengthy delay costs money and lives; it permits ongoing ecologic destruction and the infliction of needless injury; and it enables fraudsters and wrongdoers to perpetuate their misdeeds.”

Rather than alleviating these problems, H.R. 3438 would clearly exacerbate them. Accordingly, I must oppose this ill-conceived legislation.

Voting is beautiful, be beautiful ~ vote.©

Floor Statement of the Honorable John Conyers Jr. in Opposition to H.R. 3438, the “Require Evaluation before Implementing Executive Wishlists Act of 2016”


Dean of the U.S. House
of Representatives
John Conyers, Jr.
H.R. 3438, the “Require Evaluation before Implementing Executive Wishlists Act of 2016,” would stay the enforcement of any rule imposing an annual cost to the economy in excess of $1 billion pending judicial review.

Notwithstanding the bill’s colorful short title, H.R. 3438 would have a pernicious impact on rulemaking and the ability of agencies to respond to critical health and safety issues.

In essence, the bill would encourage anyone who wants to delay a significant rule from going into effect by simply seeking judicial review of the rule.

We all know that the judicial review process can take months, if not years to finalize, especially if the appellate process reaches the United States Supreme Court.

Thus, rather than ensuring predictability and streamlining the rulemaking process, this bill would have a completely opposite impact by making the process less predictable and more time-consuming.

Equally important, H.R. 3438 has absolutely no health or safety emergency exceptions. If anything, this bill would empower the very entities that caused a serious health or safety risk to delay –and possibly derail—legitimate efforts by regulatory agencies to respond to such threats.

And, as with other bills proposed by my colleagues on the other side of the aisle, this legislation myopically focuses only on the cost of a proposed rule, while ignoring the rule’s benefits, which often exceed its cost by many multiples.

In closing, there is broad agreement among experts in the administrative law field that our Nation’s regulatory system is already too cumbersome and slow-moving.

In addition to the Administrative Procedure Act’s procedural mechanisms – which are designed to ensure an open and fair rulemaking system -- Congress has passed various additional federal laws that impose further rulemaking requirements. 

And, rulemaking agencies must also comply with a number of Executive Orders issued over the past several decades that have created additional layers of analytical and procedural requirements.

The result of this dense web of existing requirements is a complex, time-consuming rulemaking process.

In response to the explosion of analytical requirements imposed on the rulemaking process, the American Bar Association, as well as many administrative law experts, have urged Congress to exercise restraint and assess the usefulness of existing requirements before considering sweeping legislation.

Imposing new analytical and procedural requirements on the administrative system also carries real human and economic costs.

As Robert Weissman, the President of Public Citizen, has observed, the cost of regulatory delay is “far more severe than generic inefficiency. Lengthy delay costs money and lives; it permits ongoing ecologic destruction and the infliction of needless injury; and it enables fraudsters and wrongdoers to perpetuate their misdeeds.”

Rather than alleviating these problems, H.R. 3438 would clearly exacerbate them. Accordingly, I must oppose this ill-conceived legislation.

Voting is beautiful, be beautiful ~ vote.©

Thursday, June 9, 2016

Statement of the Honorable John Conyers, Jr. for the Markup of H.R. 4768, the “Separation of Powers Restoration Act of 2016,” by the Committee on the Judiciary

Dean of the U.S. House
of Representatives
John Conyers, Jr.
H.R. 4768, the “Separation of Powers Restoration Act of 2016,” would eliminate judicial deference to agencies and require federal courts to review all agency rulemakings and interpretations of statutes on a de novo basis.

As a result, the bill would empower a judge to override the determinations of agency experts and to substitute his or her judgment, regardless of the judge’s technical knowledge and understanding of the underlying subject matter.

This legislation is harmful for several reasons. To begin with, H.R. 4768 would make the federal rulemaking process even more time-consuming and costly. 

This process is already severely ossified.  As the Nation’s leading administrative law scholars observed, agency rulemaking is hampered by many burdens imposed by both the courts and Congress. 

By eliminating any deference to agencies, H.R. 4768 would exacerbate this problem by forcing agencies to adopt even more detailed factual records and explanations, which would further delay the finalization of critical life-saving regulations. 

We are talking about regulations that protect the quality of the air we breathe, the water we drink, and the food we consume. 

Slowing down the rulemaking process means that rules intended to protect the health and safety of American citizens will take longer to promulgate and become effective, thereby putting us all at risk.

And, H.R. 4768 could also have the perverse effect of undermining agency accountability and transparency by encouraging clandestine rulemaking through civil enforcement actions, for instance.   

I am also concerned that H.R. 4768 will deter public participation in the rulemaking process. As the nonpartisan Congressional Research Service has observed, “[p]ublic participation in agency decision making is highly sensitive to cost and delay.” 

By imposing greater scrutiny of agency rulemaking, the bill will skew the fact-finding process in favor of those with significant resources. Large corporate interests – devoted only to maximizing profits for the benefit of their shareholders – already have the edge with their vast resources to weaken regulatory standards by burying an agency with paperwork demands and litigation.

Rather than giving more opportunities for corporate interests to prevail, we should be evaluating ways to ensure that that the voices of the public have a greater role in the rulemaking process. 

Finally, H.R. 4768 would encourage judicial activism.

By eliminating judicial deference, the bill would effectively empower the courts to make public policy from the bench even though they lack the specialized expertise that agencies possess.

Although the Supreme Court has had numerous opportunities to expand judicial review of rulemaking, the Court has rejected this approach in recognition of the fact that generalist courts simply lack the subject-matter expertise of agencies, are politically unaccountable, and should not engage in making substantive determinations from the bench.

It is somewhat ironic that those who have long decried “judicial activism,” would now support facilitating a greater role for the judiciary in agency rulemaking.

Given these concerns and others presented by the bill, I accordingly must oppose H.R. 4768.

Voting is beautiful, be beautiful ~ vote.©

Saturday, October 1, 2011

Conyers Accuses Republicans of Changing Rulemaking Process to Delay Healthcare Reform Implementation


Conyers Accuses Republicans of Changing Rulemaking Process to Delay Healthcare Reform Implementation
Slowing the Rulemaking Process Would Undermine the Authority of the Depts. Of Health and Human Services, Labor, Treasury, the Food and Drug Administration and Would Harm Consumers

(WASHINGTON) – Today, at the House Judiciary Subcommittee Hearing on “Formal Rulemaking and Judiciary Review,” Ranking Member John Conyers, Jr. (D-Mich.) criticized Republican Committee Members for their efforts to slow down rulemaking process and accused them of using legislative schemes to delay the implementation of the Affordable Care Act.

Republican Members planned the hearing and called on witnesses to discuss expanding the use of formal, trial-like requirements in the rulemaking process and push for judicial review of agency actions.   Such requirements would undermine the authority of major agencies, such as the Department of Health and Human Services, the Department of Labor, Food and Drug Administration (FDA), and the Department of Treasury (IRS) to implement the Affordable Care Act.

At the hearing, Mr. Conyers expressed the following concerns:
This Subcommittee appears to be steadfastly committed to finding ways to promote the interests of big business by hobbling and slowing down the administrative rulemaking process.  What would be the impact of slowing down the rulemaking process?  It means that rules intended to protect the health and safety of American citizens will take longer to promulgate and become effective.
                We are talking about regulations that protect the quality of the air we breathe, the water we drink, and the food we consume.  And, we are also talking about rules that ensure the safety of the cars we drive, the airplanes that convey us, and the places where we work.
                Slowing down the promulgation of these rules would only serve to put Americans at greater risk, while allowing polluters, makers of dangerous toys, and manufacturers of tainted drugs more time to avoid regulation.  Indeed, the benefits of regulation far outweigh the costs.   The latest draft Office of Management and Budget report to Congress on the cost and benefits of regulations concluded that for fiscal year 2010, federal regulations cost between $6.5 billion and $12.5 billion but resulted in between $23.3 billion and $82.3 billion in benefits. 
                In other words, even when taking the highest cost estimate and the lowest benefit estimate, the benefits of federal regulation last fiscal year were nearly double the costs. While admittedly the rulemaking process is probably not perfect, the proposals we will be discussing today will make that process much worse, not better.
                For example, the proposal to expand the use of the Administrative Procedure Act’s formal rulemaking procedures has been soundly rejected by virtually every administrative law scholar of all ideological persuasions as unnecessary and even harmful to the rulemaking process.  More than one commentator, in fact, has said that expanding the use of formal rulemaking is simply another way of telling agencies to stop issuing rules, including the kind of public health and safety rules that I just alluded to.
                It is puzzling to me why my friends on the other side of the aisle are promoting this idea when, in fact, more than a generation ago a similar idea was considered and rejected by Congress? Are we, yet again, being offered old wine in new bottles without any good reason.  Encumbering rulemaking with trial-like requirements such as cross-examination of government witnesses would not meaningfully improve the accuracy or fairness of agency decision-making.  Rather, it would greatly increase the cost and delay of issuing regulations. 
                Current informal, notice-and-comment rulemaking already imposes numerous procedural requirements.  Formal rulemaking procedures, on the other hand, would severely hamper the ability of agencies to promulgate beneficial rules or to revise or rescind existing regulations. 
                Formal rulemaking would also favor industry, which has the ability to fund protracted cross-examination and dilatory challenges to agency fact findings, while taxpayers would have to fund the agency’s ligation expenses.  And it would allow these regulated entities to effectively shape the agency’s rulemaking record to their advantage.
                There is also the risk that requiring more formal rulemaking will cause agencies to rely more on adjudications or guidance documents and other non-rulemaking processes as a means of policymaking, something that is not in anyone’s interest.  I would also be wary of statutorily creating a more stringent judicial review standard for agency rulemaking. 
                More stringent judicial review – like formal rulemaking – would make rulemaking even more costly and time-consuming for agencies.  This would force agencies to adopt more detailed factual records and explanations, effectively making it a back-door way to impose more procedural requirements on agency rulemaking.
                Also, a more stringent, less deferential judicial review standard runs the risk that judges could effectively make public policy from the bench without the specialized expertise that agencies possess.   It also could allow a judge to impose his or her personal policy preferences as part of their review of an agency rule.
                A more stringent judicial review standard opens the door to abusive litigation by well-funded business entities and others who oppose regulations generally by creating more opportunities to appeal an agency’s decisions, which would make rulemaking more costly and expensive without maximizing the benefits or minimizing the costs of regulation.
                I find it particular ironic that the Majority – which has long decried “judicial activism” and “abusive litigation by trial lawyers” – would support insinuating both of these elements as part of so-called regulatory reform efforts.
                As has been shown time and again, the benefits of regulation far exceed its costs.  Measures that ultimately are designed to hobble or prevent  regulation altogether therefore put society at risk.  This effort is just another example of how some want to allow the fox to guard the chicken coop, and we all know how well that worked given the events that led to the Great Recession. 
                Even former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan, one of the most ardent proponents of
unregulated capitalism in the marketplace, belatedly recognized he was wrong. 
                Likewise, I believe both measures that we will consider today are wrongheaded.   Perhaps it is a sign of desperation that big business – in trying to stop regulation – seeks to push long-discredited ideas that prioritizes profit over consumer protection.
                I hope we can stop wasting our time on these types of hearings – which almost fetishize corporate interest above broader societal interest – and get back to focusing on issues that matter to ordinary Americans.